Is Hell an Excessive Punishment?

Answer: This is an issue that bothers many people who have an incomplete understanding of three things: the nature of God, the nature of man, and the nature of sin. As fallen, sinful human beings, the nature of God is a difficult concept for us to grasp. We tend to see God as a kind, merciful Being whose love for us overrides and overshadows all His other attributes. Of course God is loving, kind, and merciful, but He is first and foremost a holy and righteous God. So holy is He that He cannot tolerate sin. He is a God whose anger burns against the wicked and disobedient (Isaiah 5:25; Hosea 8:5; Zechariah 10:3). He is not only a loving God—He is love itself! But the Bible also tells us that He hates all manner of sin (Proverbs 6:16-19). And while He is merciful, there are limits to His mercy. “Seek the LORD while he may be found; call on him while he is near. Let the wicked forsake his way and the evil man his thoughts. Let him turn to the LORD, and he will have mercy on him, and to our God, for he will freely pardon” (Isaiah 55:6-7).

Humanity is corrupted by sin, and that sin is always directly against God. When David sinned by committing adultery with Bathsheba and having Uriah murdered, he responded with an interesting prayer: “Against you, you only, have I sinned and done what is evil in your sight…” (Psalm 51:4). Since David had sinned against Bathsheba and Uriah, how could he claim to have only sinned against God? David understood that all sin is ultimately against God. God is an eternal and infinite Being (Psalm 90:2). As a result, all sin requires an eternal punishment. God’s holy, perfect, and infinite character has been offended by our sin. Although to our finite minds our sin is limited in time, to God—who is outside of time—the sin He hates goes on and on. Our sin is eternally before Him and must be eternally punished in order to satisfy His holy justice.

No one understands this better than someone in hell. A perfect example is the story of the rich man and Lazarus. Both died, and the rich man went to hell while Lazarus went to paradise (Luke 16). Of course, the rich man was aware that his sins were only committed during his lifetime. But, interestingly, he never says, “How did I end up here?” That question is never asked in hell. He does not say, “Did I really deserve this? Don’t you think this is a little extreme? A little over the top?” He only asks that someone go to his brothers who are still alive and warn them against his fate.

Like the rich man, every sinner in hell has a full realization that he deserves to be there. Each sinner has a fully informed, acutely aware, and sensitive conscience which, in hell, becomes his own tormenter. This is the experience of torture in hell—a person fully aware of his or her sin with a relentlessly accusing conscience, without relief for even one moment. The guilt of sin will produce shame and everlasting self-hatred. The rich man knew that eternal punishment for a lifetime of sins is justified and deserved. That is why he never protested or questioned being in hell.

The realities of eternal damnation, eternal hell, and eternal punishment are frightening and disturbing. But it is good that we might, indeed, be terrified. While this may sound grim, there is good news. God loves us (John 3:16) and wants us to be saved from hell (2 Peter 3:9). But because God is also just and righteous, He cannot allow our sin to go unpunished. Someone has to pay for it. In His great mercy and love, God provided His own payment for our sin. He sent His Son Jesus Christ to pay the penalty for our sins by dying on the cross for us. Jesus’ death was an infinite death because He is the infinite God/man, paying our infinite sin debt, so that we would not have to pay it in hell for eternity (2 Corinthians 5:21). If we confess our sin and place our faith in Christ, asking for God’s forgiveness based on Christ’s sacrifice, we are saved, forgiven, cleansed, and promised an eternal home in heaven. God loved us so much that He provided the means for our salvation, but if we reject His gift of eternal life, we will face the eternal consequences of that decision.


Why People End Up In Hell

The reason people suffer in Hell is because they do all the things you and I complain about that other people do–that you and I do, too! We want justice, just not for ourselves! We tell other people to “go to Hell” never realizing they could legitimately say the same to you and I, with good reason. The reason the divine punishment is so strong is that God is much more holy than we think He is, and you and I are way worse than we think we are. He is the holy Creator of the universe. Take a while to write down every wrong or sinful or evil thing we’ve done, and we’d be here a long time. There is truth and morality in many religions, and much beauty and insight, as well. I agree with you that there are many fine people who are not Christians. In my judgment, that is. But my judgment is not as pure as God’s. God looks at the heart and the motivation for everything we’ve done, and let me tell you, my motivations, even as a Christian, have not all been good! I need God’s ongoing forgiveness, which He has promised. Apart from God’s forgiveness and indwelling, Christian believers are the same as everybody else, if not way worse. Again, people go to Hell because they have committed sins, not because the don’t believe in a particular religion. But, we go to Heaven ~not~ because of our good works, but because of God’s forgiveness. Jesus is great, as you say, and He, not Paul, said, “Most assuredly I say to you, he who believes in Me ~has~ everlasting life.” (John 6:47) Salvation itself is received through a moment of faith in Jesus. Then, by God’s grace and the indwelling Spirit of God, we can live a life of love and goodness, to a greater or lesser degree. Everyone needs God’s forgiveness of their sins and a new life connected with God. We also as humans need transcendent meaning and the guarantee of Heaven at time of death. Through simply believing in Jesus today, you can have the same guarantee of everlasting life and Heaven the moment you die. You will also know God’s love and peace in your soul as you follow His Spirit in your spirit.

Curtis Smale